| The
difference between encyclopaedia or and a linguistic
dictionary is that the latter deals primarily with the
linguistic properties of the words (lexical units) by
dealing with meanings and functions of the words when
used in sentences, whereas the former deals with extra-linguistic
information.
Words (lexical units)
of a language signify extra-linguistic world, physical
or non-physical. A dictionary primarily giving the information
about the extra-linguistic world is called encyclopaedia.
This has nothing to do with the size of the dictionary.
It can be huge or concise. In this 'dictionary' also
the words are arranged in a particular order. But the
explanation part supplies all the extra-linguistic information
which that word signifies.
Consider the word house.
A linguistic dictionary gives its pronunciation, grammatical
information such as noun, verb etc. and its meaning
such as 'a building for dwelling in', 'a building in
general', 'a dwelling place', 'an inn',……establishment',
'one of the twelve divisions of the heavens in astrology',
'a legislative or deliberative body or its meeting place'….etc.(as
presented in the Chambers 20th Century Dictionary).
Some specialized dictionaries may give the etymology
also.
An encylopaedia, against
the entry house gives information pertaining the object
'house' such as what is a house, how many types of houses
are there, how a house is built, the designs, house-building
materials etc. with the help of drawings and photographs
etc.
The extent of information
provided by an encylopaedia has no bearing on deciding
in calling the compilation an encylopaedia. It is the
nature of information i.e., extralinguistic, or about
the objects themselves that makes a compilation an encyclopaedia.
The arrangement of words
and the explanation provided give encyclopaedias a similarity
to monolingual dictionaries. That is, encylopaedias
normally use only one language.
It must also be noted
that "the division of dictionaries into encyclopaedic
and linguistic ones is not necessarily an 'either or'
matter…. There are elements of encyclopaedic character
in almost all dictionaries. Some of these encylopaedic
elements are unavoidable, some are introduced because
the compiler of the dictionary wishes to give his work
a certain character"(Zgusta 1971:199).Therefore,
the emphasis and focus of information that makes the
dictionary an encyclopaedic or linguistic one.
We may conclude by stating
that the linguistic dictionary provides linguistic information
which includes linguistic characteristics of a word(lexical
unit)viz. pronunciation, definition, etymology, grammatical
category, etc. The encyclopaedic dictionary provides
encyclopaedic information which includes names of persons,
places and literary works coverage of all branches of
human knowledge and extensive treatment of facts, etc. |